Shakes aren’t just a dessert—they’re an experience, a comfort, and sometimes, the best pick-me-up after a long day. At Cookie Dough Monster, we know that every craving comes with a mood, and building shakes that match those emotions is what makes them so special. Whether you’re happy, stressed, nostalgic, or just looking for a sweet way to celebrate, there’s a perfect shake waiting for you.

Let’s dive into how to build shakes for every mood and why they’ve become a staple treat for all occasions.

The Comfort Shake: When You Need Something Familiar

Sometimes, life calls for the classics. When you’re feeling a little low and just want a shake that wraps around you like a cozy blanket, a traditional flavor does the trick.

• Vanilla Shake – Smooth, creamy, and made with Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla ice cream, this one is timeless.
• Chocolate Shake – Rich and indulgent, it satisfies any sweet tooth.
• Strawberry Shake – Bright, fruity, and nostalgic, this one takes you back to childhood.

These shakes are like comfort food in a glass, perfect for when you’re craving stability and familiarity. You can check out our full list of these classic flavors on our Cookie Dough Monster menu.

The Energizer Shake: For Days You Need a Boost

When you’re feeling sluggish, a shake that brings some excitement to the table can perk you right up. Adding bold flavors, crunchy toppings, or even a little peanut butter can do the trick.

• Reese Cup Shake – With Hershey’s vanilla ice cream, peanut butter, and Reese’s chunks, this shake is an energy-packed delight.
• Cookies & Cream Shake – The texture of crushed Oreos in creamy ice cream provides both crunch and sweetness.
• Strawberry Banana Shake – Fresh bananas blended with strawberry ice cream deliver natural sweetness and a refreshing kick.

These shakes don’t just fill your stomach—they bring a little pep to your step.

The Playful Shake: Perfect for Fun and Celebration

When you’re in a lighthearted, playful mood, you’ll want a shake that feels whimsical and exciting. Bright colors, fun toppings, and sweet surprises make all the difference.

• Add rainbow sprinkles for a party vibe.
• Go for cotton candy toppings or fruity syrups.
• Try a Fluffernutter Shake, made with Hershey’s vanilla, peanut butter, and marshmallow cream—it’s both fun and nostalgic.

Playful shakes are the ones you want to snap a picture of before diving in. They’re Instagram-worthy, conversation starters, and pure joy in a glass.

The Indulgent Shake: When You’re Ready to Treat Yourself

We all have those moments when moderation takes a backseat, and indulgence is the only answer. For that mood, you need layers of flavor and richness.

• Double up on ice cream scoops.
• Add brownie or cookie chunks.
• Top it with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and a cherry.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we believe indulgence is part of the fun. Pair your shake with one of our signature burgers, like the BBQ Bacon Burger, for a meal that’s as bold as your craving. See all your options on our Pigeon Forge menu.

The Nostalgic Shake: When You Want to Remember the Good Times

Nothing sparks nostalgia quite like flavors from your childhood. Maybe it’s a cookies & cream blend that reminds you of after-school treats, or a strawberry shake that brings back memories of family cookouts.

A nostalgic shake should focus on simplicity and familiarity. Consider:

• Cookies & Cream Shake with Oreos for that childhood favorite.
• A strawberry banana combo, like the ones Mom used to make.
• A classic chocolate shake with extra whipped cream, just like the diner days.

These flavors transport you back to moments worth remembering.

The Creative Shake: When You’re Feeling Adventurous

If your mood says “let’s experiment,” then it’s time to try unusual shake combinations. Mix-and-match bases, toppings, and flavors to make something entirely new.

Here are a few ways to get creative:

• Blend two ice cream bases together, like vanilla and mint.
• Add savory elements, like bacon crumbles, for a salty-sweet experience.
• Top your shake with unexpected crunch, like pretzel pieces or cereal.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we love creating custom shakes. That’s why our catering service is perfect for events where guests want to design their own combinations.

The Relaxing Shake: Perfect for Winding Down

After a long day, sometimes you just want a mellow shake that helps you relax. These flavors tend to be smoother, lighter, and calming.

• A vanilla shake with caramel drizzle creates a soothing combo.
• A strawberry shake is fruity and refreshing without being overwhelming.
• A mint-based cookies & cream shake offers a cool, refreshing end to your day.

Relaxing shakes don’t overwhelm your taste buds; they balance comfort with flavor.

The Sharing Shake: When You’re in a Social Mood

Food brings people together, and shakes are no exception. When you’re in the mood to share with friends or family, go big with a shake designed for two (or more).

• Add two straws and split a classic vanilla shake at the table.
• Build an oversized cookies & cream shake with layers of Oreos and whipped cream.
• Create a shake flight with smaller portions of multiple flavors.

Sharing shakes are about connection, laughter, and making memories. That’s why they’re always a hit at gatherings and celebrations.

Bring the Mood to the Table

At Cookie Dough Monster, we believe every shake tells a story. Whether you’re looking for comfort, creativity, or just something fun to share, there’s a shake that fits your mood. Browse our menu of shakes and burgers to see the flavors that match your cravings today.

And if you’re planning a party or event where shakes can set the mood, don’t forget our catering services. We’ll bring the sweetness to you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shakes for Every Mood

1. What’s the most popular shake for comfort cravings?
Vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry are the top comfort shake choices because they’re timeless classics.

2. Which shake is best if I need an energy boost?
Shakes with peanut butter, like the Reese Cup Shake, are a great option because they’re both filling and flavorful.

3. Can I customize shakes at Cookie Dough Monster?
Yes! You can build your own shake with toppings, mix-ins, and flavors from our menu.

4. Do you have shakes that work well for parties or events?
Absolutely. Our catering service makes it easy to serve customizable shakes for guests.

5. What toppings make a shake playful?
Sprinkles, marshmallow cream, candy pieces, and bright syrups all add fun and whimsy to your shake.

6. How do I make a shake more indulgent?
Add layers of whipped cream, sauces like caramel or chocolate, and chunks of brownies or cookies.

7. What shake flavor is best for a nostalgic mood?
Cookies & Cream or Strawberry Banana shakes tend to spark childhood memories for most people.

8. Do you offer dairy-free shakes?
Yes, we can prepare shakes with dairy-free alternatives upon request.

9. What makes shakes good for sharing?
Larger portions, multiple toppings, and extra straws make it easy to enjoy a shake with friends.

10. Are there seasonal shakes that fit specific moods?
Yes, we rotate flavors depending on the season. Check our Cookie Dough Monster menu for limited-time options.

‍