Shakes have always been a symbol of fun, indulgence, and creativity. At Cookie Dough Monster, we’ve taken the classic shake to a whole new level, giving you endless ways to build a sweet masterpiece that matches your cravings. Whether you want something nostalgic, like a rich chocolate shake, or something daring, like a shake loaded with cookie dough chunks and Reese’s Cups, the possibilities are endless when you know how to customize the ultimate shakes.

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know—from choosing the right base flavors to selecting add-ins, mix-ins, and toppings that make every sip and spoonful unforgettable.

Step 1: Start with the Perfect Shake Base

The foundation of every shake begins with its ice cream base. At Cookie Dough Monster, we use Hershey’s premium ice cream to ensure rich flavors and smooth consistency. Your first step in customizing the ultimate shake is deciding what you’re craving.

Some of our most popular base flavors include:

• Vanilla, Strawberry, or Chocolate – The timeless trio made with Hershey’s old-fashioned vanilla, strawberry, or milk chocolate ice cream. These are the best starting points for both classic and adventurous creations.
• Cookies & Cream – A fan favorite featuring Hershey’s vanilla, chocolate, or mint ice cream mixed with Oreo cookies for that perfect crunch.
• Strawberry Banana – A refreshing blend that combines Hershey’s strawberry ice cream with fresh banana, giving your shake a fruity, creamy twist.
• Reese Cup Shake – Made with Hershey’s vanilla ice cream, peanut butter, and Reese chunks, this shake already feels like a dessert dream.
• Fluffernutter – A unique combination of Hershey’s vanilla ice cream, peanut butter, and marshmallow cream.

For more flavor inspiration, you can explore our full menu of shakes and burgers to see all the classics and specialties available.

Step 2: Add Mix-Ins for Flavor and Texture

Once you’ve picked your base, it’s time to mix in the extras that make every sip unique. Mix-ins not only boost flavor but also give your shake that fun texture that makes it unforgettable.

Popular mix-ins at Cookie Dough Monster include:

• Cookie Dough Chunks – Our signature addition that sets us apart. It’s edible, safe, and adds a rich sweetness you can’t resist.
• Oreos – Crushed or whole, these cookies add a satisfying crunch.
• Brownie Bites – Perfect for chocolate lovers who want extra richness.
• Fruit Pieces – Strawberries, bananas, and cherries bring freshness and balance.
• Candy Pieces – Reese’s Cups, M&Ms, or chocolate chips for a playful touch.

Customizing your mix-ins is like building layers of personality into your shake. Want a nostalgic flavor? Stick with Oreos and chocolate chips. Looking for something over-the-top? Add cookie dough chunks and brownie bites.

Step 3: Top It Off with the Good Stuff

The crowning glory of any shake is its toppings. When you’re building the ultimate shake, the toppings are where you get to be bold, colorful, and completely creative.

Some of the most loved toppings include:

• Whipped Cream – The classic topper that makes shakes look picture-perfect.
• Caramel or Chocolate Drizzle – A sweet touch that makes every sip richer.
• Sprinkles – Fun, colorful, and perfect for kids (and kids at heart).
• Peanut Butter Drizzle – A must-have for peanut butter lovers.
• Cookie Crumbles or Whole Cookies – A favorite for Oreo fans.
• Fruit Garnishes – Strawberries, bananas, or cherries for that final pop of freshness.

Want to go extreme? Stack a cookie, donut, or brownie right on top for a shake that’s as Instagram-worthy as it is delicious.

Step 4: Balance Flavor and Texture

The secret to the ultimate shake isn’t just piling on toppings—it’s about balance. Too many rich ingredients can make a shake overwhelming, while too much fruit can overpower the ice cream base. The key is combining sweet, creamy, crunchy, and refreshing elements in a way that makes every sip enjoyable.

For example:

• A Strawberry Banana shake topped with whipped cream and fresh strawberries balances fruity freshness with creamy sweetness.
• A Cookies & Cream shake loaded with Oreos and finished with chocolate drizzle strikes the perfect crunchy-smooth contrast.
• A Reese Cup shake with peanut butter drizzle and cookie dough chunks creates an indulgent, dessert-style treat.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we help you strike that balance every time.

Step 5: Customize for the Occasion

The best part about shakes is that you can design them for any mood or occasion.

• For a hot summer day – Go with fruity shakes like Strawberry Banana or Vanilla topped with fresh fruit and a light drizzle.
• For a sweet tooth craving – Build an indulgent shake with brownie bites, Oreo crumbles, and caramel drizzle.
• For sharing with friends – Try one of our massive shakes stacked with toppings that make them perfect for group photos and fun memories.

Planning a celebration? Our catering options can bring shakes to your party so your guests can customize their own creations on the spot.

Share the Experience

Customizing shakes isn’t just about the flavors—it’s about creating an experience. When you order at Cookie Dough Monster, you’re not just getting dessert; you’re making memories with every sip and spoonful.

Looking for a place to try your own shake masterpiece? Visit our menu page and explore the endless shake combinations waiting for you.

And if you’re ready to plan your next visit or want to ask about special requests, feel free to get in touch with us. Our team loves helping customers create shakes that feel uniquely theirs.

FAQ: Customizing Shakes at Cookie Dough Monster

1. Can I order shakes from Cookie Dough Monster?
Yes! You can contact us right now and get your shake delivered to your doorstep.

2. What is the most popular shake combination?
Our Reese Cup shake with peanut butter drizzle and cookie dough chunks is a customer favorite.

3. Do you offer dairy-free shake options?
Some of our fruit and syrup toppings are naturally dairy-free, but our shakes are made with Hershey’s ice cream. Contact us for options that may suit your needs.

4. Can I order shakes online?
Yes, you can order shakes for pickup or delivery. Check out our contact page for details.

5. Do you offer seasonal shake flavors?
Absolutely. We often feature limited-time flavors to match the season, like pumpkin spice in fall or fruity shakes in summer.

6. Are your cookie dough toppings safe to eat raw?
Yes! Our cookie dough is specially made to be edible and safe.

7. Can I book shakes for an event?
Yes, our catering services include customizable shakes with all the toppings you love.

8. Do toppings cost extra?
Some premium toppings may have a small additional cost, while others are included in specialty shakes.

9. What makes your shakes different from others?
We use Hershey’s old-fashioned ice cream, edible cookie dough, and a wide variety of mix-ins that make our shakes truly stand out.

10. Can kids customize their own shakes?
Of course! Kids love choosing sprinkles, cookies, and fun toppings to create shakes that are just as playful as they are delicious.