Milkshakes are no longer just a quick, simple treat. They've become a full-on dessert experience—and the secret to taking your shake game to the next level? It’s all about the toppings. The right shake toppings can transform a delicious milkshake into a visual and flavor-packed masterpiece that you’ll want to snap photos of before you even take your first sip.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we believe that shake toppings are an art form. Whether you’re enjoying one of our signature creations or building your own custom shake, topping it like a pro is key to making it unforgettable.

Ready to learn the secrets? Here’s everything you need to know about shake toppings, from the basics to the boldest combinations.

1. Start with a Solid Foundation

Before you start piling on toppings, you need a shake that can handle the weight and flavor layers you’re about to add.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we craft our shakes using premium Hershey’s ice cream, which gives them the rich, creamy texture needed to support even the most over-the-top toppings. Whether you’re starting with our Cookies & Cream Shake or our Birthday Cake Shake, you’ve got the perfect canvas for your creations. See our full menu here to choose your shake base.

2. Pick Complementary Flavors

Pro-level shake toppings aren’t just about throwing random candies on top. The best combinations complement the base flavor of your shake.

Examples:

• Chocolate Shakes: Pair beautifully with Oreos, brownie chunks, chocolate drizzle, or Reese’s cups.
• Fruity Shakes: Match well with fresh fruit, gummy candies, or white chocolate chips.
• Nutty Shakes: Go great with peanut butter sauce, crushed nuts, or marshmallows.

For instance, our Reese Cup Shake is perfectly topped with extra peanut butter sauce and crushed peanut butter cups for a double-hit of that classic flavor.

When you’re choosing or building your shake, think about how each topping will interact with your base. Want help making the right match? Just ask our friendly team when you visit or contact us here.

3. Layer for Texture

Texture is what makes a shake really fun to drink and eat. Without texture, even the most flavorful shake can fall flat.

Pro Topping Tips for Texture:

• Crunch: Crushed cookies, pretzels, nuts, or graham cracker crumbs add a satisfying crunch.
• Chew: Cookie dough chunks, gummy candies, or marshmallow bits give you something to chew on between sips.
• Creaminess: Whipped cream, fudge sauce, or caramel drizzle add smooth, velvety layers.
• Pop: Sprinkles, popping candy, or cereal bits can add tiny bursts of fun.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we love to mix textures, like adding cookie crumbs on whipped cream for that double-layered bite.

You can explore our shake options here on the menu and get inspired to mix textures like a pro.

4. Master the Whipped Cream Swirl

No professional shake is complete without a perfect whipped cream swirl. It adds height, creaminess, and the ideal base for toppings to stick to.

How to Perfect It:

• Use a piping bag or whipped cream canister to create a tall spiral.
• Start from the outer edge and work inward to build height.
• Make sure it’s stable enough to hold additional toppings.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we finish most of our shakes with a generous whipped cream crown because it not only looks impressive but also adds to the indulgence factor.

5. Don’t Forget the Drizzle

A good drizzle can take your shake from great to Instagram-worthy.

Popular drizzles include:

• Chocolate Syrup: Classic and delicious on almost everything.
• Caramel Sauce: Adds a buttery sweetness.
• Strawberry Syrup: Perfect for fruity shakes.
• Peanut Butter Sauce: Great with chocolate or banana bases.

The trick is to drizzle not just on top, but also down the inside of the cup for that cool “waterfall” effect.

When you order from Cookie Dough Monster, ask us about adding extra drizzle to your shake—it’s one of our favorite ways to level up your dessert. See all our shake options here.

6. Go Big with Extreme Toppings

If you’ve seen those crazy, gravity-defying shakes online, you know what we’re talking about: Extreme shakes.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we specialize in shakes that are as fun to look at as they are to eat. Want to make your own? Here are some ideas:

Extreme Toppings to Try:

• Whole cookies
• Brownie chunks
• Cupcakes
• Candy bars
• Cotton candy
• Sprinkles galore

When you book us for catering, we can bring an entire shake bar where you can customize your toppings to extreme levels. Perfect for birthday parties, school events, and celebrations.

7. Use Themed Decorations

Professional-looking shakes often include themed or seasonal decorations to tie the whole look together.

Think:

• Mini flags for holidays
• Colorful paper straws
• Seasonal sprinkles (red and green for Christmas, pastels for Easter)
• Edible glitter for a sparkle effect

At Cookie Dough Monster, we love creating limited-time seasonal shakes that feature these kinds of extras. Keep an eye on our seasonal menu drops by visiting our contact page or checking in at the restaurant.

8. Presentation Matters

The cup, the layering, and the garnish positioning all play a role in shake presentation.

Pro Tips for Shake Presentation:

• Use clear cups to show off the layers and drizzles.
• Layer toppings carefully—heavier items go on the bottom, lighter items (like whipped cream and sprinkles) on top.
• Clean the rim to keep the presentation sharp (unless you’re adding rim toppings like cookie crumbs or sprinkles).

At Cookie Dough Monster, we make sure every shake looks as good as it tastes, because eating with your eyes is half the fun.

9. Customize Like a Pro

The beauty of shake toppings is that you can create your own signature masterpiece every time you visit.

Want to mix peanut butter sauce with fruity cereal? Go for it.
Prefer extra cookies on top of a birthday cake shake? We’re all about it.

Check out our full menu here and start thinking about your next shake creation.

For special events or group gatherings, our catering services let you and your guests build their own shakes with a toppings bar, taking customization to the next level.

10. Don’t Be Afraid to Get Messy

The best shakes are big, bold, and sometimes a little messy. That’s part of the fun! The key is to embrace the experience—the drizzles down the cup, the towering whipped cream, the toppled cookie bits—it’s all part of what makes shake-topping an art form.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we believe that every shake should be a celebration, whether you’re grabbing dessert after a long day or celebrating a birthday with friends.

Conclusion: Shake Topping is an Art—Let’s Get Creative

If you’ve ever wondered how those over-the-top shakes are built, now you know—it’s all about layering textures, complementing flavors, creative drizzles, and fearless toppings.

Whether you’re visiting Cookie Dough Monster in Pigeon Forge, ordering your favorite shake from our menu, or customizing your own creation at one of our catered events, you can top your shake like a pro by following these simple steps.

The next time you grab a shake, don’t just stop at whipped cream—pile it high, get creative, and make your shake a show-stopper. We can’t wait to see what you come up with!

‍