When it comes to breakfast, most people think of eggs, bacon, pancakes, or a bowl of cereal. But shakes? That’s where the debate gets interesting. For some, shakes are a dessert or an indulgence after dinner. For others, they’re a grab-and-go option that feels fun yet filling. So, is having shakes for breakfast really a good idea—or is it just a tasty excuse to start the day with dessert?

Why People Love the Idea of Shakes for Breakfast

Shakes are quick, convenient, and customizable. In a world where mornings often feel rushed, sipping on something cold and flavorful can be an easy win. Plus, shakes provide a level of creativity that standard breakfast foods often lack. Whether you’re going for classic flavors like Vanilla or Chocolate, or mixing it up with something exciting like a Reese Cup Shake, the options make mornings feel less boring.

At Cookie Dough Monster, we see plenty of people come in early, craving something that’s both refreshing and satisfying. Our Fluffernutter Shake with peanut butter and marshmallow cream often doubles as a protein-packed choice for those looking for a sweet but hearty start.

Nutritional Considerations: Can Shakes Actually Be Balanced?

Not all shakes are created equal. Some are loaded with sugar, while others can provide a balanced mix of nutrients. The key to making shakes a reasonable breakfast option is to look at the ingredients.

Adding fruit, like in our Strawberry Banana Shake, gives you natural sweetness and a dose of vitamins. Meanwhile, shakes like Cookies & Cream or Reese Cup lean more indulgent, perfect for those mornings where you just want to treat yourself.

For people seeking balance, pairing your shake with something savory—like our hand-cut fries from the menu—can round out your breakfast and keep you feeling full longer.

When Shakes Are a Great Morning Option

There are moments when shakes make total sense for breakfast:

1. Busy mornings – When you need something quick but still crave flavor.
2. Vacation vibes – Especially in a place like Pigeon Forge, where indulgence is part of the fun.
3. Post-workout fuel – Flavors like Vanilla or Fluffernutter can be satisfying and energizing.
4. Weekend treats – Perfect for when breakfast is more about enjoyment than efficiency.

And with dessert catering options, you can even bring the morning shake trend to events like brunch parties or work celebrations.

Why Some People Say "No"

Of course, shakes for breakfast aren’t for everyone. If you’re looking for low-sugar, high-protein starts to the day, not all shakes fit the bill. Heavier flavors like Reese Cup might feel like too much first thing in the morning for some people. But that’s the beauty of shakes—you can tailor them to fit your mood and cravings.

Bringing Creativity to Morning Shakes

Part of the charm of starting your day with a shake is the ability to customize it. Want extra fruit? Blend in strawberries or banana. Craving something richer? Go for a double shot of peanut butter or an Oreo crumble topping.

Our Fluffernutter, Cookies & Cream, and Strawberry Banana shakes are perfect examples of how creative combinations can turn a simple shake into something special, even before 10 a.m.

Thinking of Making Shakes Part of Your Morning Routine?

If you’re considering shakes as a breakfast staple, it helps to think of them like any other meal: balance and variety matter. Some mornings might call for something fruity and fresh; others might demand indulgence. At Cookie Dough Monster, we’re all about making sure your shake matches your mood.

Something to Try Tomorrow Morning

Whether you’re visiting Pigeon Forge or live nearby, why not start your day differently? Pair a Strawberry Banana Shake with some crispy fries, or grab a Vanilla Shake to enjoy alongside a savory burger from our menu. You might just find that shakes for breakfast aren’t as unconventional as they seem.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shakes for Breakfast

1. Are shakes actually good for breakfast?

Yes, depending on the ingredients. Fruit-based shakes like Strawberry Banana can provide vitamins and natural sweetness, making them a refreshing morning option.

2. Which shakes are best for mornings?

Flavors like Vanilla, Strawberry, or Fluffernutter tend to feel lighter and more balanced for breakfast.

3. Can I pair shakes with other breakfast foods?

Absolutely! Pairing shakes with fries or even a breakfast-style burger can make for a satisfying morning meal.

4. Are shakes too sugary for breakfast?

Some shakes are indulgent, but you can balance them by choosing fruit-based options or customizing your shake to reduce sweetness.

5. Do you offer catering for breakfast events?

Yes, our catering services can bring customizable shake bars to your morning events.

6. Can shakes give me enough energy to start the day?

Shakes with protein-rich ingredients, like Fluffernutter, can provide lasting energy.

7. Are your shakes made with real ingredients?

Yes, all our shakes are crafted with real fruit, Hershey’s ice cream, and quality mix-ins for a true flavor experience.

8. Do locals actually drink shakes in the morning?

Yes! Many of our regulars enjoy shakes as a fun way to kick off their day, especially on weekends or vacations.

9. What’s the most popular morning shake?

Strawberry Banana is a top choice among customers looking for a refreshing start.

10. Where can I order shakes for breakfast?

You can visit our shop in Pigeon Forge or explore our menu online to plan your perfect breakfast shake.

‍