There’s something deeply comforting about a milkshake. Whether it’s the creamy texture, the chill of the ice cream, or the indulgence of toppings and syrups, shakes manage to feel both nostalgic and modern all at once. They’re one of those rare desserts that defy the trends—always present, always evolving, and always delicious.

But how did milkshakes come to be? What’s the history behind this iconic treat, and why do people still crave them today, decades after their invention? To understand their enduring charm, let’s take a deep dive into the origin of milkshakes, their transformation over time, and their place in today’s dessert culture.

The Humble Beginnings: Milkshakes in the 1800s

Believe it or not, the original "milkshake" was not the frosty, sweet beverage we know and love today. The first recorded use of the term dates back to the late 1800s, but it referred to something closer to an alcoholic tonic. In an 1885 newspaper, milkshakes were described as “a sturdy, eggnog-type drink with whiskey, eggs, and other ingredients.” They were marketed as both a health tonic and a treat for adults.

However, by the early 1900s, the term began to shift in meaning. As soda fountains and ice cream parlors gained popularity in America, milkshakes gradually evolved into non-alcoholic, creamy drinks made with milk, flavored syrups (like chocolate or vanilla), and sometimes crushed ice.

The Soda Fountain Era: Shakes Go Mainstream

The 1920s and 1930s saw the rise of the soda fountain and diner culture—arguably the golden age of milkshakes. This was when shakes began to solidify their identity as a sweet, frothy dessert drink.

A major breakthrough came with the invention of the electric blender in 1922 by Stephen Poplawski. This device made it possible to quickly and consistently mix milk, ice cream, and syrup into a smooth, frothy beverage. Suddenly, shakes became much easier to prepare, and their texture improved dramatically. With this innovation, milkshakes became a staple of American diners, often served in tall glasses with whipped cream and a cherry on top.

During this time, flavors began to expand. Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry were the foundational trio, but regional variations and creative mix-ins started emerging. The milkshake had officially entered American pop culture.

The Drive-In Boom: Shakes and Car Culture

The post–World War II era ushered in a new chapter for milkshakes. As cars became more affordable and fast food culture emerged, drive-in restaurants and burger joints exploded in popularity during the 1950s and 60s.

This was the era when the milkshake became forever linked with burgers, fries, and jukeboxes. Teens in poodle skirts and leather jackets would gather at their local drive-ins, sipping on thick shakes while listening to rock and roll. Shakes weren’t just drinks—they were social symbols, representing youth, freedom, and Americana.

Some chains even started introducing extra-thick shakes—the kind you almost needed a spoon to enjoy. These dense, indulgent versions were known as "frosteds" or "concretes" in certain regions and added to the appeal of shakes as a satisfying dessert experience, not just a beverage.

Shakes in the 80s and 90s: Reinvention and Innovation

As food culture grew more experimental in the 1980s and 90s, so did milkshakes. While fast food chains like McDonald’s and Burger King kept the traditional shake alive, boutique diners and gourmet dessert shops started to put a spin on the classic drink.

This period saw the rise of flavored syrups, candy mix-ins, and even entire dessert-inspired shakes. Cookies & cream, peanut butter cup, mint chocolate chip—these once-niche flavors became fan favorites. Toppings like whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and crumbled cookies became common, and shakes began to resemble sundaes in a glass.

Blended desserts like smoothies and frozen coffee also started trending, but shakes remained the gold standard of indulgent frozen drinks. They were no longer just nostalgic—they were cool again.

The Modern Shake: Over-the-Top and Instagram-Worthy

In the 2010s and beyond, shakes entered a new phase of reinvention, thanks to the rise of social media. Dessert spots around the world began crafting “freakshakes”—monstrous, towering milkshakes topped with entire slices of cake, donuts, candy bars, marshmallows, and more.

These creations were designed for visual impact as much as taste. Places like Black Tap in New York City popularized the trend, and soon, shake shops across the globe were racing to create the most outrageous, photo-ready concoctions.

But even as shakes embraced the wild side, many shops returned to their roots—focusing on quality ingredients like premium ice cream, real fruit, and handcrafted syrups. Artisanal shake shops found a balance between innovation and tradition, offering both classic favorites and creative spins that kept customers coming back.

Why Shakes Still Matter Today

So what makes shakes so timeless? Why, after more than a century, do we still love them?

1. Nostalgia in Every Sip

For many people, a milkshake brings back childhood memories—visits to the diner with family, Friday nights with friends, or hot summer days cooling off with a frosty drink. That nostalgia is a powerful emotional connection that few other desserts can match.

2. The Perfect Balance of Flavors and Textures

Milkshakes hit the sweet spot—literally. They’re creamy, cold, smooth, and rich. Whether you’re drinking one through a straw or scooping it with a spoon, a shake satisfies like no other dessert drink.

3. Endless Customization

From flavor base to toppings, syrups, and mix-ins, no two shakes have to be the same. This level of customization makes them fun and creative. You can go classic or totally wild, depending on your mood.

4. They’re Shareable (and Social Media Friendly)

Whether it’s snapping a pic for Instagram or splitting a monster shake with friends, milkshakes are inherently social. They’re made to be shared and talked about—especially the over-the-top versions that double as conversation pieces.

Shakes in Pigeon Forge: A Local Favorite

Here in Pigeon Forge, milkshakes have found a devoted fan base among both tourists and locals. With the town’s family-friendly attractions and retro charm, it’s the perfect place for a shake renaissance. Restaurants and dessert bars like Cookie Dough Monster are helping keep the tradition alive—offering hand-crafted shakes that blend high-quality ingredients with pure fun.

At Cookie Dough Monster, shakes aren’t just about flavor (though they’ve got that covered with options like Reese Cup, Fluffernutter, and Cookies & Cream). They’re about the experience—from the first taste of Hershey’s Old Fashioned ice cream to the last spoonful of crushed topping.

Whether you’re stopping by after a day at Dollywood or grabbing dessert after dinner, a visit to Cookie Dough Monster is a reminder of why shakes have stayed so beloved for so long.

A Classic That Never Quits

From its humble origins as a boozy health tonic to its current status as a creative dessert superstar, the milkshake has come a long way. And yet, through every decade and trend, it’s managed to keep its place in our hearts—and on our menus.

The timeless appeal of shakes lies in their ability to adapt without losing their core identity. They’re fun. They’re satisfying. And they’re built for memories.

So next time you're craving something sweet, cold, and utterly nostalgic, skip the trends and go for the classic. Better yet, head to your local shake shop and see how this century-old treat continues to reinvent itself—one delicious sip at a time.

‍