There’s nothing quite like a perfectly blended shake. Whether you’re craving something nostalgic, indulgent, or completely off the wall, a custom shake can be the perfect canvas for creativity. At Cookie Dough Monster, we know a thing or two about crafting show-stopping shakes. That’s why we’ve pulled together the ultimate guide to help you create your own signature shake right at home.

From choosing the right base to mastering the blend and adding next-level toppings, here are our best tips for making a shake that’s not just delicious—it’s totally you.

1. Start with a Quality Ice Cream Base

The foundation of every great shake is quality ice cream. A rich, creamy base ensures your shake tastes indulgent and smooth with every sip. Go for premium ice cream brands that use real dairy, minimal additives, and strong, recognizable flavors.

If you love classic flavors, try vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry. Feeling bold? Opt for cookies & cream, peanut butter cup, or salted caramel. The base you choose sets the tone for every other flavor you layer on top.

2. Pick a Liquid That Complements, Not Competes

The next ingredient is your liquid—milk or a milk alternative. This helps your shake blend smoothly and creates the drinkable texture you’re aiming for.

Whole milk adds richness, while almond, oat, or coconut milk can introduce subtle new flavors. For extra indulgence, consider adding chocolate milk or even flavored creamers that pair well with your chosen ice cream.

Pro tip: Start with a small amount (about ¼ to ½ cup per 2 scoops of ice cream), and add more only if needed.

3. Add Flavor Mix-ins

Now it’s time to personalize. Flavor mix-ins can be anything from cookie crumbles to fruit, candy, syrups, or even breakfast cereals. This is where your shake becomes unique to you.

Some winning combinations:

• Peanut butter + banana + chocolate ice cream
• Strawberry ice cream + fresh strawberries + graham crackers
• Cookies & cream ice cream + crushed Oreos + fudge sauce
• Vanilla ice cream + cinnamon toast cereal + maple syrup

Experiment with combinations until you find something that excites your taste buds.

4. Choose Your Toppings Wisely

Toppings are what take your shake from good to unforgettable. They provide texture, extra flavor, and visual appeal.

Try:

• Whipped cream
• Crushed cookies or candy bars
• Gummy candies
• Drizzles of chocolate, caramel, or peanut butter sauce
• Sprinkles, nuts, or cereal

The key is balance. Don’t overload your shake with so many toppings that it overshadows the base flavors. Instead, highlight the key ingredients with complementary textures and colors.

5. Presentation Is Everything

Want to make your signature shake feel truly special? Presentation matters.

Use a clear glass jar or tall shake glass to showcase layers. Rim the glass with chocolate or caramel and roll it in sprinkles or crushed cookies before filling it up. Top it with a dollop of whipped cream and one or two statement toppings, like a whole cookie, marshmallow, or candy bar.

Not only does it taste amazing, but it looks social media-worthy too.

6. Don’t Forget About Texture

A perfect shake strikes the right balance between thick and sippable. To nail the texture:

• Use less liquid if you want a thicker consistency.
• Add more ice cream or frozen ingredients like banana or yogurt for creaminess.
• Blend just enough to combine, but don’t overdo it—over-blending can melt your shake too quickly.

Also, avoid using ice unless you want a frosty or slush-like result. Ice can water down the flavor.

7. Make It a Meal or Dessert

Shakes can do double duty as dessert or a fun meal replacement. For a more filling shake, consider adding protein powder, oats, or Greek yogurt. These ingredients increase satiety while keeping the flavor intact.

For dessert shakes, go all in with indulgent ingredients: brownie chunks, cookie dough bites, toffee, or even a slice of cake blended in. Want inspiration? Visit our Menu to see how we craft dessert-forward shake creations at Cookie Dough Monster.

8. Test and Perfect Your Recipe

Signature shakes take some trial and error to perfect. Play with proportions, test flavor combinations, and get feedback from friends and family.

Create a recipe card once you’ve nailed your signature blend, so you can remake it easily. You might even want to name it after yourself or the occasion it was made for!

9. Serve It with Style

The final tip? Make the shake experience feel like a treat.

Serve with a reusable or colorful straw, fun drink stirrers, or personalized cups. Share your creation at parties, BBQs, or game nights. You can even set up your own DIY shake bar with toppings and mix-ins so friends can build their own signature shakes.

Hosting an event? Check out our Catering options at Cookie Dough Monster—we’ll bring our shake expertise straight to your party.

10. Know When to Let the Pros Handle It

Sometimes, the best shake is the one you don’t have to make yourself. If your creation journey has you craving the ultimate blend without all the work, stop by Cookie Dough Monster. From Fluffernutter to Reese Cup and Cookies & Cream, we offer next-level shakes made with Hershey’s Old Fashioned ice cream and handcrafted toppings that never miss.

Need something sweet right now? Reach out via our Contact page, and we’ll hook you up with a shake worth dreaming about.

Creating your own signature shake is all about having fun, exploring new flavors, and making something that reflects your personal cravings. Whether you go for nostalgic classics or wild new combos, the shake world is wide open.

Just remember: the best shake is the one that brings a smile to your face—and maybe a little whipped cream to your nose.

‍