When it comes to creating the ultimate milkshake, the toppings are what take a good shake and turn it into a masterpiece. At Cookie Dough Monster, we believe that the perfect shake should be a sensory overload—in the best way possible. From crunchy textures to gooey drizzles, our lineup of toppings is designed to turn every shake into a crave-worthy experience you won’t forget.

Whether you're looking to expand your dessert horizons or find your new favorite indulgence, here are some unique shake toppings you absolutely need to try now.

1. Edible Cookie Dough

It’s no surprise that edible cookie dough tops our list. After all, it’s in our name! This rich, creamy topping is more than just nostalgia—it’s a satisfying, doughy dream made safe for raw consumption. Whether you scoop it on top of a classic vanilla shake or mix it into something more adventurous, cookie dough adds that chewy texture and sweet flavor that takes your dessert to the next level.

📌 Check out all the ways we incorporate cookie dough into our shakes and desserts on our menu.

2. Toasted Marshmallows

Toasted marshmallows are the gooey, golden upgrade you didn’t know your shake needed. We torch these babies to perfection—slightly crispy on the outside, melty on the inside—and top your shake for that campfire vibe. Perfect for shakes with chocolate, peanut butter, or even fruity bases.

3. Cereal Crumble

Why limit cereal to just breakfast? Fruity Pebbles, Cap’n Crunch, Cinnamon Toast Crunch—you name it, we’ve crushed it. Adding cereal crumble on top of your shake not only gives it a colorful punch but also an exciting crunch that brings childhood memories flooding back.

4. Cotton Candy Fluff

Talk about Instagram-worthy! A swirl of cotton candy on top of your shake adds both flavor and flair. It melts into the shake like a sugary cloud, infusing every sip with carnival vibes. If you love fun, whimsical desserts, this is your go-to topping.

Looking to plan a party that serves these picture-perfect treats? Visit our catering page to learn more about our custom dessert bars and shake stations.

5. Chocolate-Dipped Pretzels

Sweet and salty combos are always a win, and nothing nails it like chocolate-dipped pretzels. They add crunch, saltiness, and a chocolatey finish to your shake. Stick them straight up for a fun garnish or crumble them for texture—it’s a satisfying contrast you’ll keep craving.

6. Whipped Cream Mountains

Sure, whipped cream might not seem that unique, but when you pile it high and drizzle it with sauces, sprinkles, or crushed candy, it becomes something magical. Our whipped cream is house-made, light and airy—perfect for balancing out the richness of your shake base.

7. Crushed Candy Bars

Love Reese’s Cups? Snickers? Butterfingers? We’ve got ‘em. Crushed candy bars make a great mix-in or topping for added texture and intense bursts of flavor. Combine your favorite candy with complementary ice cream flavors for an ultra-customized experience.

Pro tip: If you want help creating your dream shake, just ask one of our team members when you stop by our shop or contact us online!

8. Brownie Bites

Dense, fudgy brownie bites are a chocolate lover’s dream. These rich cubes of decadence sit proudly on top of your shake or swim inside for a double chocolate delight. When paired with a chocolate or cookie dough base, you’re looking at one of the most indulgent shakes imaginable.

9. Caramel & Chocolate Drizzles

It’s not just about what’s on top—it’s about the presentation and flavor integration. We use premium caramel and chocolate sauces to drizzle down the inside of your cup and across the top of your shake. It adds flavor, contrast, and pure dessert drama.

10. Gummy Candy Garnish

Fun, chewy, and colorful, gummy candies like bears, worms, or sour strips add a playful twist to your shake. They’re especially popular with kids (and kids at heart). Want a shake that screams fun? Add some gummies on top and enjoy the chew!

11. Cheesecake Cubes

Yes, this is real. We top shakes with cheesecake cubes for the ultimate dessert-on-dessert experience. Creamy, tangy, and rich, these bites are a unique surprise that elevate any fruity or vanilla-based shake.

12. Waffle Cone Pieces

Crushed waffle cones offer a satisfying crunch and a touch of nostalgia. It's like having a milkshake and an ice cream cone in one. The golden brown pieces hold up well in cold drinks and bring a buttery contrast to smooth textures.

13. Sprinkles Galore

Sprinkles might be common, but we use them creatively—rainbow, chocolate, seasonal blends—on everything from birthday-themed shakes to celebration treats. They're festive, fun, and the easiest way to add a bit of color and joy.

14. Churro Bites

Spiced with cinnamon sugar and fried to golden perfection, churro bites are a bold and unexpected topping. They’re best served warm atop a cool shake, giving you temperature contrast as well as a mix of crispy and creamy textures.

15. Donut Halves

Why have a shake or a donut when you can have both? We top some of our most indulgent shakes with halves of real donuts. It’s over-the-top, sure—but it’s also unforgettable. If you’ve never had a donut on a milkshake, you're missing out.

Want to Try These Toppings?

You’ll find all of these incredible shake toppings—and more—at Cookie Dough Monster. From classic favorites to creative inventions, we’re here to help you discover your next dessert obsession.

Ready to browse everything we’ve got to offer? Explore our full menu now. Planning a celebration or event? Our shake catering options are guaranteed to impress your guests—check out the catering page for all the details.

Got a question or a special request? Reach out through our contact form—we’re always happy to help you find your perfect flavor combo.

Because at Cookie Dough Monster, dessert isn’t just something you eat—it’s something you experience.

‍