There’s something magical about the perfect shake—it’s nostalgic, satisfying, and capable of turning an ordinary day into something a little sweeter. But in a world full of dessert shops and frozen drink chains, what really makes one shake better than the rest?

At Cookie Dough Monster, we’ve made it our mission to create shakes that stand out from the competition, and the reasons why are layered in every swirl of Hershey’s Old Fashioned ice cream, every hand-picked topping, and every smile we serve alongside it.

Let’s break down what makes our shakes different—and why so many locals and visitors alike keep coming back for more.

It Starts with Premium Ingredients

At the heart of every unforgettable shake is the ice cream. While some places cut corners with low-grade dairy or artificial flavors, we believe in sticking with the good stuff. That’s why all of our shakes begin with Hershey’s Old Fashioned ice cream, known for its creamy texture, rich flavor, and quality you can taste from the first sip.

Whether you’re going for a classic Vanilla, Strawberry, or Chocolate, or getting wild with a Reese Cup or Cookies & Cream blend, the base is always built on real-deal ice cream that tastes like childhood in a cup.

Craving something bold? Check out our full menu of shakes and burgers to find your next go-to treat.

Unique Flavor Combinations You Won’t Find Anywhere Else

One thing that makes our shakes stand out from the competition is the creativity we pour into every recipe. We don’t just stick with the basics—we remix them into something brand new.

Take our Fluffernutter Shake, for example. It’s not just peanut butter and vanilla. It’s a blend of peanut butter, marshmallow cream, and Hershey’s ice cream that delivers a flavor bomb of sweet and salty goodness.

Then there’s the Strawberry Banana, made with strawberry ice cream and real banana—not syrup. And if you want pure indulgence, the Reese Cup Shake combines peanut butter with chunks of Reese’s candy for that crave-worthy combo no one can resist.

Every shake is a result of flavor engineering, and it’s why fans keep coming back to try every one on the list.

Real Ingredients. No Shortcuts.

If you’ve ever had a shake that tasted like chemicals or was overly sugary, chances are it was loaded with artificial flavors and cheap mix-ins. We skip all of that. The only way to deliver shakes that stand out from the competition is to use real, high-quality ingredients in every cup.

We use:

• Real strawberries and fresh banana
• Authentic Oreos, not off-brand substitutes
• Rich peanut butter
• Creamy marshmallow fluff
• Chunks of real Reese's Cups

Our mission is simple: when you order a shake, you deserve the real thing. And that’s what you get at Cookie Dough Monster.

Consistency That Never Misses

Ever ordered a shake that was too runny? Or worse, so thick it clogged your straw? The perfect shake should be drinkable but still spoonable, satisfying without being too rich. And that balance? We’ve nailed it.

Our team knows that blending technique matters. It’s not just about throwing everything in a mixer. We make sure the consistency is just right, every time. That’s why when you order one of our shakes—whether it’s your first or your fiftieth—it tastes exactly how you remember it.

A Shake Shop with Personality

Shakes should be fun, and your dessert experience should come with a smile. At Cookie Dough Monster, we’re more than just a shake stop—we’re a vibe. From the friendly staff to the nostalgic design and energetic feel of our shop, we’re here to make your treat feel like a celebration.

Whether you’re in Pigeon Forge on vacation or a local dropping by for a weekend pick-me-up, our goal is to make every visit memorable. Looking for dessert catering that’s equally unforgettable? Our catering service brings our shake magic straight to your event.

So Good, You’ll Want Us at Every Party

Shakes are great solo, but they’re even better when shared. And that’s why our catering options are quickly becoming a go-to for birthdays, team celebrations, school events, and more.

When it comes to dessert bars, we don’t just offer standard fare. We roll up with customizable shake stations, letting guests pick their base and toppings for a totally unique dessert experience.

If you’re planning an event and want to blow your guests’ minds with the best dessert in town, hit us up through our contact page. We’ll bring the flavor—and the fun.

Built for Cravings, Perfect for Anytime

Our shakes aren’t just an afterthought—they’re the main event. Whether it’s 2 p.m. on a sunny afternoon or 8 p.m. after dinner, there’s never a wrong time to indulge.

We’ve designed our menu to hit every kind of craving. Classic lovers? You’ll want to try Vanilla or Chocolate. Looking for something different? Fluffernutter or Strawberry Banana will knock your socks off. Need something rich and satisfying? Reese Cup’s got your name all over it.

With our variety of flavors, textures, and add-ins, we’ve created shakes that people crave at all hours.

Get in Touch for the Real Deal

Thinking about your next dessert run? Don’t waste time with bland options that won’t hit the spot. If you're after shakes that stand out from the competition, it’s time to head to Cookie Dough Monster.

We’re here, we’re local, and we’re ready to shake things up—literally. Whether you’re ordering online, planning a party, or just need something sweet right now, reach out to us here. We’ve got your shake fix covered.

Why the Locals Love Us (and Tourists Do Too)

Cookie Dough Monster has become a staple in Pigeon Forge not just for the bold, delicious shakes—but for how we make people feel. Tourists who try our shakes often come back again before they leave town. Locals? They bring their friends. Some even bring their parents and grandparents for the full family shake day.

That’s the kind of love you get when you offer something that’s not only tasty—but done right. Our shop is about people just as much as it is about shakes, and that’s a combination you don’t find everywhere.

A Sweet Spot That Actually Delivers

We know convenience matters. If you’re searching for the best shakes near you, we’ve made it easy to grab and go—or get it delivered. Whether you’re craving Cookies & Cream from your couch or a Reese Cup Shake for that movie night, our shop is ready to roll.

No long wait times. No soggy delivery mess. Just the perfect shake, made to order, and prepped to impress.

Ready for Something Better?

There are shakes. And then there are shakes that stand out from the competition. At Cookie Dough Monster, we don’t settle for average—and we don’t want you to either.

Next time that craving hits, swing by and taste the difference for yourself. Or plan ahead and get in touch with us to bring shake greatness straight to your next event.

Either way, just know—we’re not your average shake stop. We’re Cookie Dough Monster. And we take dessert seriously.

‍