Best Milkshakes in Pigeon Forge, TN

If you're looking for the best milkshakes in Pigeon Forge, Cookie Dough Monster is the stop to make. Every shake starts with Hershey's old fashioned ice cream and is blended thick, 16 ounces at a time, in over 40 flavors ranging from classic chocolate and strawberry to loaded specialty shakes like S'mores and Cookie Dough Bites. Located just steps from The Island on Teaster Lane, it's the easiest dessert stop to add to a day in Pigeon Forge.

Why Cookie Dough Monster Makes the Best Milkshakes in Pigeon Forge

Cookie Dough Monster has been voted among the Top 10 Restaurants in Pigeon Forge, and the milkshake menu is a big reason why. Every shake is made with Hershey's ice cream, blended to order, and served in a full 16oz size. With more than 40 flavors on the full menu, there is a shake for every craving, from timeless favorites to specialty combinations you will not find anywhere else in town.

What sets these shakes apart:

• Made with Hershey's old fashioned vanilla ice cream as the base
• Full 16oz size on every shake, all priced at $7.00
• Over 40 flavors across chocolate, strawberry, peanut butter, and specialty categories
• Any shake can be made into a malt for an additional $0.25
• Shakes can be added to any burger meal for +$7.00 with the Grab A Pair add-on
• Located directly across from Nike Clearance Store, near The Island in Pigeon Forge

Curious what makes a shake shop stand out in the first place? Our post on why our shakes stand out from the competition breaks down what goes into every batch.

Over 40 Milkshake Flavors

Want the full rundown flavor by flavor? Check out exploring the world of shakes one flavor at a time for the deep dive. Here's the lineup by category:

Chocolate-Based Shakes

• Chocolate
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Chocolate Cherry
• Mint Chocolate
• Death by Chocolate (cookie dough)
• Dirty Brownie
• Caramel Mocha Chip

Strawberry-Based Shakes

• Strawberry
• Strawberry Banana
• Strawberry Marshmallow
• Strawberry Nutella
• Strawberry Shortcake

Peanut Butter Shakes

• Peanut Butter
• Peanut Butter Banana
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Fluffernutter
• Reese Cup

Specialty Shakes

• S'mores, made with toasted marshmallows, graham crackers, and Hershey bar
• Banana Pudding, made with banana pudding mix and Nilla wafers
• Cookie Dough Bites, blended with 3 of your favorite cookie dough flavors
• Maple Waffles & Bacon, made with Liege waffles, maple syrup, and crumbled bacon
• Cookies & Cream
• Cake Batter
• Cotton Candy

Flavors rotate and expand regularly, so the full lineup on any given visit may include even more options than listed here. Not sure where to start? Our guide on how to choose the perfect shake based on your mood can help narrow it down, and our most popular shakes you cannot miss covers the crowd favorites.

Shake Details and Pricing

All Thickies Thick Shakes are 16oz and priced at $7.00 each. Want it richer? Any shake can be turned into a malt for just $0.25 more.

Curious what actually makes a shake this thick? Read what makes a shake thick and creamy or how we create thick and creamy shakes every time.

Make It a Meal

Already ordering a burger? Add a milkshake to any burger meal for +$7.00 with the Grab A Pair add-on, no extra trip to the counter required. See how to pair your burger and shakes for the perfect meal for pairing ideas, or check out the full menu to build your own combo.

Traveling with kids? Kid-approved shakes loved by families across East Tennessee and family-friendly shakes perfect for your Smoky Mountain adventure both have picks the whole table will agree on.

More Than Milkshakes

Milkshakes are just the beginning of the dessert menu at Cookie Dough Monster. Also on the menu:

• Scooped Hershey's ice cream (1, 2, or 3 scoops)
• Root Beer Float made with A&W root beer
• Homemade edible cookie dough bites in 17+ flavors
• Side Splitters banana split
• Funnel cake fries
• Waffle-ly Cute Ice Cream Sandies made with mini Liege waffles

See the full menu for the complete lineup of burgers, chicken sandwiches, grilled cheeses, and desserts.

Visit Cookie Dough Monster in Pigeon Forge

Address: 2660 Teaster Lane, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863Phone: (865) 366-1444 (call or text)Location: Directly across from the Nike Clearance Store, near The Island, Rocky Top Mountain Coaster, Pigeon Forge Snow, and the Old Mill District

Order for pickup by calling or texting, dine in, or order delivery through DoorDash. Have questions before you visit? Contact us or check the FAQ page.

Contact Us | Order on DoorDash | View Full Menu

Also Serving Sevierville and Gatlinburg

Staying nearby instead of in Pigeon Forge? We're a short drive from both. See our shake pages for Sevierville and Gatlinburg as well.

Frequently Asked Questions About Our Milkshakes

What is the best milkshake at Cookie Dough Monster?With over 40 flavors, the best milkshake comes down to preference. Popular picks include classic Chocolate and Strawberry, specialty flavors like S'mores and Cookie Dough Bites, and the Maple Waffles & Bacon shake for something unexpected.

How much do milkshakes cost?All Thickies Thick Shakes are 16oz and priced at $7.00 each.

Can I make my shake a malt?Yes, you can make any shake a malt for an additional $0.25.

Are the milkshakes dairy-free?Cookie Dough Monster's shakes are made with Hershey's ice cream, which contains dairy. Contact the restaurant directly to ask about specific accommodations. For lower-dairy options elsewhere, see dairy-free shakes that taste just as good.

Can I add a shake to my burger meal?Yes, you can add a milkshake to any burger meal for +$7.00 with the Grab A Pair add-on.

What ice cream brand does Cookie Dough Monster use for its shakes?Cookie Dough Monster uses Hershey's ice cream for all of its shakes and scooped ice cream.

For the complete list of frequently asked questions, visit our full FAQ page.